Eating horse meat is controversial in culinary culture throughout the world, although it is a common food in the Netherlands, Belgium, France, Italy, the Great Buffalo Commons in the United States and in some parts of the Canadian prairies. The act of eating it is fraught with history, tradition, nutritional, animal rights, legal and emotional argument. It is not only sanctioned, but also embraced in some countries — while being nearly or totally illegal in others. This article takes a deep dive in to the history and role in various societies that horse meat has played, the science behind eating it and the moral and legislative questions that have evolved along with it.
Historical Context
Horse meat has been eaten for thousands of years. Wild horses were hunted by prehistoric humans as food. Since the start of domestication, 4,000 to 6,000 years ago, as historian and writer James Wynbrandt has documented, horses have been indispensable to world civilizations as a means of transportation, as a labor-saver on farms and as an implement of war — and even at times as sustenance.
Horses were eaten during periods of severe food shortage in early European societies and by people trying to travel loads of stuff through tough terrain. But as Christianity became a predominant religion, the appearance of horse meat was considered a relic of pagan times and forbidden by the Church. Even the Catholic Pope Gregory III outlawed the eating of horse meat as unclean in 732 AD. As with religious proscriptions, horse meat remained, however, a faintly eaten but poorly admitted meat, particularly among the poor who had little access to meat in general.
Horse meat became especially popular in Europe during the Napoleonic wars and again during the World Wars when food shortages were rampant. In the 19th and early 20th century, nations like France have legalized and normalized its consumption to the point of having horse butcher shops or boucheries chevalines.
Global Cultural Importance
Horse meat is revered and cursed, as customs and taboos vary by region.
Horse Meat Eaters Cross here for a tour of the minutes diet across all borders, courtesy of Foodney.com.
France: Horse meat is eaten in France largely as a meat that is tender and lean. French butchers often separately sell it, apart from other meats, and it is used in dishes like steak de cheval.
Italy: Horse meat is a culinary tradition, especially in the southern regions such as Sicily and Apulia, where it is used in various dishes, including of course grilled or stewed.
Kazakhstan and Mongolia: Horse meat is integral to the diet and culture. It is frequently eaten dried, boiled, or smoked. In these nations, horses are revered as the providers of nomadic life, though eating horse meat is not seen as a taboo.
Japan: In some regions such as Kumamoto and Nagano, raw horse meat, basashi, is served sashimi-style. It is considered a delicacy.
China and Russia: In northern areas and rural states, horse meat has been a part into their traditional cuisine, cooked with herbs and spices in larger meals.
Nations Where Consuming Horse Meat is Considered Taboo or Banned
United States and United Kingdom: Horses in the United States and United Kingdom are treated as pets of companionship and sport, not food. While it is technically legal to eat horse meat in the U.S., horse slaughterhouses have been defunded, making it a non-practice.
Ireland and Australia: As with their close relative, the U.K., cultural beliefs about horses—subtly tied to equestrian and racing traditions—have led to horse meat being largely reviled as a food product.
India and Israel Religion-based taboos and customs, such as the religion-based ban in Judaism and Hinduism, may affect consumption of horse meat.
Horse Meat Nutritional Facts
But, if you can get past the controversies around eating it, horse meat is healthier than other types of red meat “people eat every day”, as Seoul Shik said, such as commonly eaten beef and pork. It is:
High protein: Horse meat provides approximately 20–25 grams of protein per 100 grams making it a rich source of high-quality protein.
Low fat: usually only 2–5% fat, making it leaner than beef.
High in iron: More heme iron than beef, which is easily absorbed by the human body.
Rich source of omega-3 fatty acids: Particularly in horses that are raised under pasture conditions, the fat content is reaching levels similar to in some fish.
Less cholesterol: Better for people who watching their heart health.
Ethical and Animal Welfare Implications
The question of whether it is socially acceptable to eat horse is at the centre of an international debate. There are a number of issues to consider for animal welfare supporters:
Emotional Attachment
Horses are frequently viewed as a thinking, feeling being, which humans can form deep relationships with. In a lot of places they are thought of more as dogs — companions rather than livestock. This emotional attachment plays a large role in psychological resistance to eating horse meat.
Management and Slaughter Standard
Horse slaughter for meat is widely criticized for its cruelty and lack of regulation in some countries. Horses, which are not raised for the purpose of meat, are often shipped long distances under horrific conditions, heightening their stress and injuries. Horses may be more difficult to stun humanely than cattle and so add further issues.
Unregulated Drug Use
Racing and other performance horses are frequently medicated with substances, particularly drugs, that have not been approved for use in animals raised for human food. This poses potential health risks to consumers and challenges the regulatory control process.
Legal Landscape
The legality of horse meat differs substantially across the world:
Horse meat is legal and regulated for export in Canada, Mexico and Belgium.
United States In the U.S. eating horse meat is not illegal, although in Illinois public opinion is being converted and designation of horse as livestock has been effected. No horse slaughter houses operate legally in the United States due to the defunding of inspections.
The European Union permits the sale of horse meat but insists on stringent labelling and traceability rules, brought in after a 2013 scandal in which horse meat was passed off as beef.
Brazil and Argentina are some of the world’s largest horsemeat exporters to Europe but with relatively no internal consumption.
Economical and Ecological Considerations
The horse meat trade, though it’s a niche trade, has a place in the global meat trade:
Exports: Nations such as Canada, Argentina, Mexico export many tons of horse meat to Europe and Asia.
Value for money: Horse meat is usually less expensive than beef, especially during hard times like the economic downturn.
Sustainability: Horses eat less feed and drink less water than cattle and produce less methane, so under certain circumstances they are a more benign source of red meat.
But for ethical and other reasons, and because of limited demand, it’s a dying market in much of the world.
Contemporary Patterns and Public Opinion
Public attitudes to eating horse meat are still changing:
Falling Out of Favor in Europe: In France and Italy, horse meat was once a staple but is now falling out of favor with changing tastes and animal welfare campaigns.
Revival in Japan: A renewed interest in traditional foods, such as basashi, is taking hold, particularly among younger people who are looking for some cultural bona fides.
{Other animals (non-Cow) are not really other animals: There is a sort of growing opposing movement that speaks to the rising complex line of sustainable/protein food sources; horse meat these days is occasionally thrown into conversations about supply, sustainability, and to some extent the global food security debate.
To date, negative public perception and ethical concerns have prevented acceptance for general use.
Conclusion
Its also one of the most divisive foods in the world: horse meat. It is considered a traditional part of some cultures as a culinary treat of high nutritional value or even as a gourmet food, while other cultures do not consume it due to moral repugnance. The dispute over horse meat isn’t just about individual tastes, but about palpable cultural traditions, ethical considerations and, increasingly, public policy.
Given the constant evolution of food systems, the future of horse meat may depend on how societies weigh tradition against modern values about animal welfare, sustainability, and the global distribution of nutrition.
Want to read a version of this this article as a PDF, or reprint it?
